Manatee Protection Plan-Phase I
Manatee Protection Plan — Phase I
Introduction
The Florida manatee (Trichechus manatus latirostris), a subspecies of the West Indian manatee, is a year-round inhabitant of the coastal waters and rivers of Volusia County. Listed as an endangered species and designated the marine mammal of Florida, the average adult measures 8–9 feet in length and weighs approximately 1,000 pounds. Manatees are herbivores, feeding primarily on aquatic plants, and are generally found in water 3–6 feet deep.
Manatees cannot tolerate water temperatures below 20°C (68°F) for extended periods. When temperatures drop, animals inhabiting Volusia County waters migrate to warm water refuges — most notably Blue Spring State Park, identified as the single most important natural warm water refuge on the central east coast of Florida.
The historic range of the West Indian manatee extends from northern Brazil through Mexico, the southeastern U.S., and the Caribbean. During summer months, animals have been reported as far north as Chesapeake Bay. Gestation is approximately 13 months; most females give birth to a single calf. Newborns range 4.0–4.5 feet in length and weigh about 66 pounds, remaining dependent on their mothers for up to two years.
The purpose of this plan is to provide county-wide protection for the Florida manatee and its habitat. This plan contains recommendations for vessel speed zones, marina/boat facility development, shoreline and submerged land development, habitat protection, law enforcement, educational programs, human-manatee interaction, and inter-governmental coordination.
The goal of county manatee protection plans is to ensure the long-range protection of manatees and their habitat. Objectives for Volusia County's Manatee Protection Plan (MPP) include:
- Reducing the number of boat-related manatee mortalities
- Achieving an optimal sustainable manatee population
- Protecting manatee habitat
- Promoting boating safety
- Developing public education keyed to the need to protect manatees and their environment
- Taking into consideration the rights of citizens to use Volusia County waters for recreational and commercial purposes
Inventory and Analysis
Manatees are found in Volusia County year-round on both the Intracoastal Waterway (ICW) and St. Johns River (SJR) systems, with distinct summer and winter distribution patterns. Human activities — including boating, netting, and improper disposal of monofilament line — pose ongoing threats. Five manatee deaths in the county since 1974 are attributed to drowning in nets and ingestion of monofilament line.
| Level | Authority / Legislation | Key Provisions |
|---|---|---|
| Federal | Marine Mammal Protection Act (1972); Endangered Species Act (1973) | Prohibits harassment, hunting, capture, or killing; requires conservation and recovery plans |
| State | Florida Manatee Sanctuary Act (1978); Ch. 68C-22 F.A.C. | Established Florida as a manatee refuge and sanctuary; authorizes boat speed regulations; manatee is official Florida State Marine Mammal |
| County | Volusia County Comprehensive Plan, Ch. 11 & 12 | Requires MPP development; criteria for marina siting; boat speed regulation and enforcement; manatee sanctuary identification |
| City | City of Ormond Beach (Tomoka River Manatee Sanctuary, 1988) | Slow/idle speed zones; prohibition of personal watercraft and air boats; no new marina development; one boat slip per parcel |
On the ICW, manatees use the channel primarily as a travel corridor during warm months. Significant congregation areas include the Tomoka River, Manatee Cove (Mosquito Lagoon), the sewage outfall near the New Smyrna Beach city library, the outfall near the Seabreeze Bridge, and the canal by English Jim's Marina.
On the SJR, manatees congregate at Blue Spring during winter months. Blue Spring is the only natural warm water refuge in the county. During warm months, manatees travel throughout the river system. Radio-tracking data documents manatee use from the Lake George/SJR confluence to Lake Monroe.
Volusia County's perinatal mortality rate (44.1%) is notably higher than the statewide figure (21.2%). The Tomoka River/Basin, downtown Daytona Beach area, and Ponce Inlet backwaters are the primary concentrations of perinatal deaths, reflecting their importance as calving areas. The ICW system recorded 116 manatee mortalities; the SJR system (including portions of Lake and Seminole counties) recorded 42.
A comprehensive boating study of the SJR and ICW systems collected data via aerial surveys, ramp intercept interviews, boat ramp trailer census, shoreline dock surveys, marina surveys, and a mail survey to 2,050 registered boaters.
- Main activities: traveling and fishing (86% of all boating activity)
- Primary boat type: outboard engine powerboats averaging 100 horsepower; Class 1 (16–25 ft) and Class A (<16 ft) accounted for 88% of boats observed
- 50% more boats on water in summer vs. winter
- 51% of boaters were Volusia County residents; 46% from other Florida counties; 3% out-of-state
- Marine facilities in county: 100 boat ramps, 77 marinas with 5,346 slips, and ~4,100 shoreline docks
- Ratio: 1 boat per 20.2 residents
| Rank | Area | Primary Activity | Notable Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mosquito Lagoon | Recreational fishing | Only significant seagrass beds on the ICW; includes Canaveral National Seashore |
| 2 | Ponce DeLeon Inlet Area | Ocean access, fishing, sailing | Only ocean access for 60+ miles; Disappearing Island sandbar; Smyrna Dunes Park |
| 3 | Tomoka River / Tomoka Basin | Fishing, cruising, crabbing | Designated manatee sanctuary by City of Ormond Beach; part of Tomoka Marsh Aquatic Preserve |
| — | Greater Daytona Beach Area | Travel corridor | Halifax Harbor Marina (500+ slips, 2nd largest continuous marina on U.S. east coast) |
| Rank | Area | Primary Activity | Notable Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Silver Glen Springs ("The Glen") | Recreation, picnicking, fishing | 100+ boats observed at one time; overnight trips common; 36% of boaters named it as destination |
| 2 | Lake Dexter / Lake Woodruff / Norris Dead River | Fishing (especially winter) | 100+ boats counted at 8 am during winter aerial surveys; popular with out-of-state winter visitors |
| 3 | Hontoon Island / Lake Beresford | Picnicking, water sports, fishing | ~40 slips at Hontoon Island State Park; houseboat rentals; Blue Spring SP nearby |
| 4 | Lake Monroe | Sailing, fishing, personal watercraft | 572 wet slips (Seminole Co. side); large, unobstructed water surface; grass flats on north/east shores |
Volusia County's Environmental Management Service Center maintains a water quality monitoring program on both the ICW and SJR, implemented in late 1989. Both water bodies are sampled quarterly with data uploaded to the USEPA STORET system. Overall water quality appears good with no major pollution point sources identified.
Stormwater runoff has been identified as a major habitat quality concern, particularly along the Tomoka River and its tributaries. The County contracted comprehensive stormwater studies resulting in recommendations for projects totaling over $98 million in capital expenditures and $4 million in annual O&M expenses. Non-point surface water runoff — estimated to account for up to 80% of pollution in some water bodies — is the primary challenge.
ICW System: Seagrass beds (primarily Cuban Shoal Grass and Manatee Grass) are located throughout Mosquito Lagoon from the Brevard County line to Edgewater, with scattered beds up to Ponce Inlet. North of Ponce Inlet, tannin-darkened water restricts seagrass growth; the predominant SAV is marine algae. Manatees in the Tomoka River area feed on smooth cordgrass. Exotic/nuisance species of concern: Brazilian Pepper and Elephant Ear.
SJR System: Diverse plant communities include submerged, emergent, and floating vegetation. Preferred manatee food plants identified by Bengtson (1981): Water Hyacinth, Pickerelweed, Alligatorweed, Paragrass, Giant Reed, and Cattail. Primary exotic problem: water hyacinths (double mass in 6–14 days under optimal conditions), water lettuce, and hydrilla. Army Corps of Engineers (ACOE) is responsible for maintenance spraying.
Volusia County addresses manatee habitat protection through its Comprehensive Plan (Ch. 11 Coastal Management Element and Ch. 12 Conservation Element), a county-wide surface water monitoring program, extensive public lands ownership, and an active land acquisition program.
- Lake Woodruff National Wildlife Refuge
- Blue Spring State Park
- Tomoka State Park & Tomoka Marsh
- Canaveral National Seashore
- Mosquito Lagoon
- Spruce Creek and named tributaries
- Tomoka River and tributaries (Little Tomoka River, Groover Branch, Priest Branch, Misner's Branch, Thompson Creek, Strickland Creek)
- Bulow Creek State Park; DeLeon Springs State Recreation Area; Murray Creek (including Rose Bay)
Several existing education programs support manatee protection in Volusia County. Blue Spring State Park offers the most comprehensive program, including K–12 VCR presentations (4x daily, 400+ children/day), field observation classes, weekend adult programs, and summer camper programs. Additional programs are operated by Canaveral National Seashore, Save the Manatee Club (SMC), Florida Power and Light, Sea World, Florida Fish and Wildlife Commission, and Volusia County Environmental Management (VCEM).
Permit and development review for marine facilities potentially affecting manatees may involve: the municipality (if applicable), Volusia County, FDEP, St. Johns River Water Management District (SJRWMD), U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (ACOE), Florida Fish and Wildlife Commission (FWC), and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS). The ACOE and FDEP maintain a joint application for dredge-and-fill projects including boat docking facilities.
Manatee Protection Plan Recommendations
Speed zones were established in 1991 for both the SJR and ICW systems under Rule 68C-22.012, F.A.C. Volusia County is currently divided into 26 speed zones with 11 classifications on the SJR, and 29 zones with 10 classifications on the ICW. Zone types include idle speed, slow speed, 25 mph, 30 mph, 35 mph, seasonal idle/slow, shoreline buffer zones, and nighttime slower speeds.
From the 1996 Boating Activity Study (954 boaters): 22% indicated signs were "not necessary / not in correct areas / need to be less restrictive"; 6% found signs "too confusing." Only 32% reported they slowed down or were more cautious. The Bureau of Protected Species Management (now FWC) stated preference that speed zone development/modification be handled through the State's rule-making process.
From 1974–1998, a total of 37 manatees were killed by watercraft in Volusia County (25 on the ICW, 16 on the SJR). There were 15 mortalities in the nine years prior to the 1991 speed zones, and 22 in the nine years after. The lack of major congregation areas outside Blue Spring suggests that location-specific speed zones may need reassessment.
The Volusia County Sheriff's Marine Unit (primary agency), FWC Division of Law Enforcement, Florida Park Patrol, and U.S. Coast Guard all provide enforcement services. Approximately four vacancies exist within the three FWC squads covering Volusia County waters. Three additional officers and equipment were recommended by FMP at an estimated cost of $105K.
Pursue additional FWC funding for three additional on-water officers to increase enforcement capabilities in Volusia and surrounding counties, in addition to filling currently approved vacant positions.
Multiple agencies share overlapping duties. Coordination is critical given finite resources: FWC focuses on resource violations and ecosystem management; the Sheriff's Department primarily targets manatee speed zone violations.
Establish an annual meeting between all enforcement agencies (FWC, Volusia County Sheriff's Marine Unit, Canaveral National Seashore, Florida Park Service, USCG, USFWS) to coordinate enforcement activities, designate agency "manatee specialists," and consider use of aerial and compliance surveys.
Actively explore ways to clarify and consolidate signage relating to boating regulations.
Include the 1-888-404-FWCC phone number with all boater education and waterfront property owner information materials for reporting dead/injured manatees and manatee protection violations. Attempt to inform all registered boaters of any regulatory changes via mass mailing (Rec. C4.1).
Volusia County (primarily through VCEMSC, the Port Authority, and the Halifax/Indian River Task Force) will actively support the IRLNEP CCMP Action Items covering water/sediment quality, biodiversity preservation, seagrass restoration, wetlands, land acquisition, endangered species, fisheries, and monitoring. The County will also review the CCMP to determine how best to achieve similar results in the Halifax River (Rec. D1.1).
VCEMS will continue its water sampling program in partnership with SJRWMD. A new water quality monitoring program will be established on Strickland Creek (monthly sampling, 3–5 year baseline period). VCEMS will assist the County and cities in planning the transition of waterfront properties from septic tanks to sewer connections (Recs. D2.1–D2.3).
Extend the Florida Yards and Neighborhoods Program to SJR property owners with informational mailings on environmentally sound landscaping and watering techniques.
VCEMS will coordinate with FDEP to identify SJR areas requiring a balance of manatee habitat protection and aquatic plant control, and work with ACOE on treating clogged finger canals. Only FDEP-approved herbicides by licensed applicators; copper-based herbicides are prohibited in state waters. Herbicides containing endothall and fluridone are most acceptable (Recs. D4–D4.1).
VCEMS will support the County's Public Works Department with water quality monitoring for stormwater projects, with attention to Strickland, Thompson, and Dodson creeks. The County should develop a comprehensive stormwater management strategy (Recs. D5–D5.1).
Continue pursuit of the Spruce Creek CARL property, the Lake Woodruff corridor, and Indian River Lagoon Blueway project properties. Work with Tomoka Geo-Park to pursue acquisition of the Strickland/Thompson/Dodson creeks confluence property. Develop an inventory of irreplaceable manatee resources including feeding, calving, nursing, and migratory route areas. Review and refine existing regulations to minimize additional water quality degradation and cumulative development impacts (Recs. D6–D6.3).
All dredged material shall be contained on an upland site. New and maintenance dredging on the ICW should be performed November 15 – March 15, when feasible. Dredging in areas of abundant seagrasses will be prohibited.
Education initiatives are categorized by implementation timeline:
| Rec. | Initiative | Timeline | Target Audience |
|---|---|---|---|
| E1 | Manatee Education Coordination — designate staff position; utilize interns and Enviro-Net volunteers | Short Term | Internal / all |
| E2 | Manatee info & waterproof speed zone maps distributed with new boat registrations; floatable keychain with FWC rescue number; info stickers for rental vessels | Near Term | Boat owners & operators |
| E3 | Manatee educational brochures distributed to all residents (e.g., enclosed with utility bills or municipal newsletters) | Short Term | All county residents |
| E4 | Manatee education segments for USCG Auxiliary and U.S. Power Squadron boating safety courses | Near Term | Boat owners & operators |
| E5 | Public service announcements — use existing PSAs from SMC, FDEP, Duval County; movie theater slides | Short Term | General public |
| E6 | Manatee information kiosk displays at high-use ramps; "Adopt a Ramp/Kiosk" program — FIND committed to funding | Long Term | Boating public |
| E7 | Coordinate with fishing tournament organizers to distribute manatee information and speed zone maps | Short Term | Tournament boaters |
| E8A | GIS-based ramp signs showing 5-mile speed zone sphere of influence for each ramp | Near Term | Boat operators |
| E8B | Improve manatee sign distribution — 80% of marinas and 69% of ramps currently display no manatee information | Short Term | Marina/ramp patrons |
| E9 | "Manatee Friendly Marina" designation incentive program | Short Term | Marina patrons |
| E10 | 30-second Manatee Traveler's Alert on NOAA Weather Radio (Brevard County has established favorable NOAA contact) | Short Term | All boaters |
| E11 | Interactive manatee educational computer program for schools (coordinate with SMC) | Long Term | School children / public |
| E12 | Manatee information segment on Volusia County website (habitat, speed zones, migration, Blue Spring counts, prop guard info) | Short Term | General public |
| E13 | Monofilament line recycling receptacles at high-use boat ramps (Berkeley provides receptacles free; pays UPS postage) | Near Term | Boaters / fishermen |
| E14 | No Feeding/Watering signs at high-interaction areas (SMC provides signs at no cost) | Short Term | County residents |
| E15 | Manatee educational curriculum for K–12 and adult education programs (coloring books, speed zone maps, brochures) | Short Term | Students |
| E16 | Enhanced mandatory boating education for operators under 16 and for violation offenders — support state legislation | Near Term | Boat operators |
| E17 | Bi-annual abandoned nets and crab traps clean-up on SJR and ICW (coordinate with FWC, Sheriff's Office, VCEM, Enviro-Net) | Near Term | All stakeholders |
| E18 | "Please Watch for Manatees" signs available at County offices for private dock owners (SMC supplies free of charge) | Short Term | Waterfront property owners |
| E19 | Aquatic plant control information to all waterfront property owners (spraying risks, mechanical control, native replanting) | Near Term | Waterfront property owners |
| E20 | Marine cleaning agents / chemical information to marina owners (FDEP Clean Marina program) | Near Term | Marina operators |
| E21 | Disseminate official FWC "idle speed" and "slow speed" definitions with all boater education materials | Short Term | Boat owners & operators |
| E22 | Volusia County Manatee Fact-Sheet — contextualizes all threats; widely disseminated | Short Term | General public |
| E23 | FIND Boater Handbooks distributed with boat registrations | Short Term | Boat owners & operators |
Volusia County leads all counties in the proportion of perinatal deaths (44.1%). VCEMS recommends increasing FFWCC/FMRI research into causes of high perinatal mortality, including study of hormone-disrupting chemicals. VCEMS will coordinate with SJRWMD to develop a comprehensive water quality data analysis and reporting program (Recs. F1.1–F1.2).
Additional FWC research on manatee use patterns in Volusia County should be conducted. VCEMS will coordinate with USGS and provide staff, volunteers, and boats to assist.
Repeat the boating activity study every five years on a smaller scale: two aerial survey flights each in summer and winter, a marina inventory, and boat ramp census.
F4: Design and implement a speed zone compliance study in coordination with FFWCC. F5: If funding permits, research the economic impact of manatee protection. F6: Continue collection of data on environmental stressors affecting manatee health.
| Rec. | Action |
|---|---|
| G1 | Establish reporting mechanism whereby FMRI sends County mortality summaries and rescue reports each quarter beginning 1998 |
| G2 | Establish reporting mechanism with Blue Spring State Park rangers for monthly manatee counts during congregation months |
| G3 | Request additional data and input from USFWS, FFWCC/FMRI, and BPSM; request advance notification of any manatee research planned in the County |
| G4 | Ensure final MPP is consistent with Volusia County's Comprehensive Plan (and vice versa) |
| G5 | Convene annual program coordination meeting with VCEMS, FFWCC/FMRI, BPSM, USFWS, and Sirenia Project (open public meeting; post to County website) |
| G6 | Establish formal communication link with Tomoka Geo-Park for exchange of manatee use data |
| G7 | Contact each municipality to assign a manatee liaison; periodically request time on commission agendas to update municipalities on MPP status |
| G8 | Work with waterfront cities on water quality issues, including sharing water sampling program data |
| G9 | Contact Volusia County School Board to explore feasibility of a public school manatee information coordinator |
| G10 | Incorporate USGS telemetry data (formally requested from the Sirenia Project) into the MPP |
A full-time County Manatee Program Coordinator position should be created and funded to manage the MPP program.
| Phase | Timeframe | Key Actions |
|---|---|---|
| Short-Term | < 1 year after FWC approval | Initiate ongoing manatee education initiatives; conduct initial water quality analysis on existing data; formulate plans and partners for research beyond Blue Spring |
| Near-Term | 1–3 years after FWC approval | Implement ongoing education initiatives; complete water quality analysis; establish mechanisms for increased enforcement; develop criteria for evaluating MPP effectiveness |
| Long-Term | > 3 years after FWC approval | Continue ongoing education initiatives; update Boating Activity Study within 5 years; update and modify MPP as needed |
| Annual Report | Ongoing | Volusia County shall prepare an annual report on MPP implementation status; request yearly FWC Save the Manatee Trust Fund Annual Report beginning 2001 |